Which Is The Best Vegan Protein Supplement? | Comparing Vegan Protein

vegan protein supplement smoothie

 

These days it shouldn’t be a surprise to anyone that vegans have no problem whatsoever getting enough protein from normal everyday food. This myth is long done, dead, buried.

However, many vegans are trying to grow bigger, stronger, and more powerful by lifting heavy objects and really pushing our bodies. For this purpose, it’s beneficial (1) to go beyond average recommendations and increase our protein intake. One of the easiest ways to do so is via vegan protein supplements.

Optimal protein intake

It is recommended to consume at least 2 grams of protein per kg of lean body mass (2).

Say I weigh 90 kg, minus 20% body fat. That’s 72 kg lean body mass. 72 kg * 2 g protein equals 144 g of protein per day.

That’s one huge plate of tofu!

This is where protein supplementation comes in. There’s nothing magical about it but it’s a convenient way of getting some extra protein.

For vegans, this usually means one of four types: soy protein, hemp protein, brown rice protein, or pea protein.

Amino Acid Profiles

We won’t get too bogged down with sciency stuff but let’s just get the foundations in place.

Protein is made up of smaller building blocks – amino acids. There are 21 amino acids which are useful for our bodies and we can actually produce all but nine of them (the essential amino acids).
Basically, we have to eat these nine.

How much though? That’s what the Dietary Reference Intakes (DRI) tells us:

Ideal Amino Acid Profile

Quite a lot of leucine, lysine, and tyrosine. A little less valine. Even less threonine, isoleucine, methionine, and histidine. Not very much tryptophan.

If a protein hits those levels it’s called a complete protein.

Let’s see how our vegan proteins stack up to that.

Soy Protein

A complete protein (3). Plenty of leucine, tyrosine, valine, and isoleucine (three of which are the branched amino acids – BCAA).

Soy Protein profile

Hemp Protein

Hemp is close to having enough of some amino acids but it’s not really a complete protein (4). If we had to do a hemp protein vs whey comparison, hemp protein couldn’t rival whey’s profile. That doesn’t make it bad though – it just means you shouldn’t replace all your meals with anything but hemp protein shakes.

Hemp Protein profile

Rice Protein

Rice protein has an abundance of some amino acids, in addition to most of the branched ones (5). The only one missing to make it a complete protein is lysine.

Rice Protein profile

Pea Protein

Pea protein has most of the amino acids covered but is a little low in tyrosine and methionine (6).

Pea Protein profile

Bonus: mixed protein

Rice protein is lacking lysine but has plenty of tyrosine and methionine. Pea protein on the other hand has plenty of lysine but lacks some tyrosine and methionine.

So what do you do? You combine them!

This is a popular blend because the texture of pea protein makes for a nice complement to that of rice protein. It tastes a lot better together and it’s seen as the best vegan protein combination.

Personally, I’ve only had a chance to try our Vegan Protein Powder (Chocolate Peanut Flavour) but I’ll attest to the taste.

Your Pick

Whatever protein powder you pick should be completely up to your own personal preferences. Any differences between the two types won’t stretch very far beyond the paper it’s written on.

Found one that tastes great? Sounds like a good candidate. Or one that finally doesn’t cause problems with your sensitive stomach? Go for that!

Eating loads of food and topping that up with the occasional Vegan Protein Powder is also a good strategy.

References:

(1) Metabolic advantages of higher protein diets and benefits of dairy foods on weight management, glycemic regulation, and bone.

(2) Protein and amino acids for athletes.

(3) Evaluation of the protein quality of an isolated soy protein in young men: relative nitrogen requirements and effect of methionine supplementation.

(4) PROTEIN: Hemp Protein Powder

(5) Amino Acid Composition of an Organic Brown Rice Protein Concentrate and Isolate Compared to Soy and Whey Concentrates and Isolates.

(6) Pea Protein Powder

Did you enjoy this article?

Thank you for your feedback

Related Products